During his time in college, Caleb Williams earned a reputation for making all sorts of highlight-reel plays once plays broke down. He had an uncanny sense for avoiding pressure, scrambling out of trouble, and making pinpoint passes down the field for big plays. Scouts and experts called it “putting on the Superman cape.” Williams had to do that a lot in 2023, trying to make up for his team’s obvious deficiencies on offense and defense. While it was incredible to watch at times, many worried that he was becoming too reliant on the approach.