Family makes terrifying discovery in basement following growing suspicions

A Harding University professor and his family in Arkansas discovered a stranger had been living in their basement after noticing items mysteriously going missing from their home.

Dutch Hoggatt said in an interview with KTHV that he first suspected something was off when he noticed a pair of shoes he normally leaves near the home’s back door were gone.

"I asked my wife if she had thrown them away, and she had not," he told the outlet. "Over time, we noticed that chairs had been moved around in the house.