Nancy Guthrie’s neighbor noticed ‘atypical’ pet behavior night of disappearance, earlier date: report

A neighbor of Nancy Guthrie says his dogs woke him in the middle of the night on two dates now under scrutiny, behavior he described as unusual, including the night authorities believe she was abducted.

Jeff Lamie, who lives a few houses from Guthrie’s Catalina Foothills home, told "Crime Stories with Nancy Grace" that his dogs woke him and wanted to be let outside on Jan. 11 and again in the early morning hours of Feb. 1.

Lamie said the late-night activity stood out because it was not normal for his dogs.