With opt-outs back in focus after Tatsuya Imai signing, is the Phillies’ stance prohibitive, advantageous or both?

GM Preston Mattingly recently said the Phillies “don’t do” player opt-outs. Is that a self-imposed obstacle or an advantage? (Cheryl Pursell)

On its face, Tatsuya Imai’s three-year, up-to-$63 million contract with the Houston Astros seemed like a deal the Phillies could’ve beat. Especially given their interest in establishing themselves in the Japanese market and finding a player to get the ball rolling. Especially given their reported interest in Imai himself.

But if you take...