Sarah Jessica Parker Reveals the Surprising A-Lister She Dated Before Matthew Broderick

Well, we didn’t have this on our 2025 Bingo card — Sarah Jessica Parker confirming a long-standing rumor about her dating life in the early 1990s.

The 60-year-old actress spilled the tea to Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live on July 13, and our mouths were on the floor. Cohen wanted to know if the story about her dating her Honeymoon in Vegas co-star Nicolas Cage was true.

Her reply? “Um, yes, I did,” Parker said, per Us Weekly. “Yes, I did.”

Cohen quipped, “Oh, wow.