‘It Felt Like a College Improv Group’: Two Tony Voters Debate Their 2025 Ballots

Photo-Illustration: Vulture; Photos: Emilio Madrid, Marc Brenner, Julieta Cervantes

Stage Whisperer and our anonymous Tonys voters are in agreement: It’s a strikingly robust season for Broadway, one in which 42 new musicals and plays have opened. Simply, there was a lot to keep up with, even for the professionals. Some shows were destined to be cash-grab dirges. Others were just head-scratchingly great. Buena Vista Social Club, Death Becomes Her, and Maybe Happy Ending were awarded the most Tony nominations with ten each...