Remedy's Control was a seminal hit, managing to blend the studio's signature third-person action with paranormal touch points like SCP, The X-Files, and Twin Peaks. Trying to find high-quality games of the same ilk can be a little difficult, but there are some good options out there for fans of paranormal mystery.
For the sake of this feature, story and atmosphere are more important than genre. It's also taken for granted that people should check out Remedy's Alan Wake, which is so similar...